Witch Finger Cookies Zoom

Witch Finger Cookies Recipe

Shhh?Our secret Witch Finger recipe calls for cocoa powder, almond and vanilla extract. Buttery, finger-licking-good Witch Finger Cookies feature a slivered almond manicure. Wet your witches? whistles with Alicia?s Blood-Red Punch made with Tito?s Vodka, Gran Mariner, pomegranate and orange juice, lemonade, club soda and a dash of cinnamon.
Makes: Makes about 3 dozen cookies.
Skill Level:

Product Actions

Additional Information

Step 1

Preheat oven to 350°F. Prepare Wilton Finger Cookie Pan cavities with vegetable pan spray.

Step 2

In large bowl, combine flour and salt.

Step 3

In large bowl, beat butter and sugar with electric mixer at medium speed until well blended. Beat in egg, vanilla and almond extracts; mix well. Add flour mixture; beat until well blended. Remove half of dough; set aside. Add 2 tablespoons cocoa powder to remaining dough; mix until completely incorporated.

Step 4

Press dough into prepared pan cavities, filling 2/3 full.

Step 5

Bake 9-10 minutes or until light brown around edges. Cool in pan 10 minutes. Turn pan over; lightly tap pan to remove cookies. Cool completely on cooling grid.

Step 6

To decorate, spread a small amount of melted chocolate on one side of sliced almond, press gently to adhere to tip of cookie.

Do you have everything you need to get started?
Supply List
Viewing Options
Detailed List Simple List


1/2 teaspoon No Color Almond Extract ((optional))


In Stock (ships in 1-2 business days)

1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract


all purpose flour

2-3/4 cups all purpose flour


1 teaspoon salt

butter, softened

1 cup (2 sticks) butter, softened

granulated sugar

1-1/2 cups granulated sugar


1 egg

cocoa powder

2 tablespoons cocoa powder

chocolate, melted

1 ounce chocolate, melted

sliced almonds

3 tablespoons sliced almonds




large bowl

large bowl

Electric mixer

Electric mixer

Item(s) added to the shopping cart!

View Shopping Cart Continue Shopping

Item(s) added to your Favorites!

View Favorites Continue Shopping