skip to content

FREE SHIPPING on all orders over $60! *Limited to domestic U.S. orders only.

The Eyes Have It Cookies

Whether it’s Halloween or just a fright night gathering, these bloodshot eyeball cookies add to the scare factor. With Sugar Sheets!™ Edible Decorating Paper and tools you create these eye-popping treats in an instant.


Difficulty: Easy


Step 1

Prepare and roll out cookie dough. Cut cookies using larges circle from Round Cut-Outs. Bake and cool. Ice top smooth with buttercream icing.

Step 2

For whites of eyes, use punch with largest Circles Cutting Insert and White Sugar Sheets! Position on cookie with Piping Gel.

Step 3

To make iris: Use the large open end of tip 3 to circles from Red, Light Green and Bright Yellow Sugar Sheets! colors. Position on cookie with Piping Gel.

Step 4

For pupil, use punch with smallest Circles Cutting Insert and Black Sugar Sheets! Position on iris with Piping Gel.

Step 5

Use red FoodWriter to draw lines on whites of eyes.