Prepare Icing We suggest that you tint all icings at one time while the Elmo cake cools. Refrigerate tinted icings in covered containers until ready to use.
Make 3 cups of buttercream icing: Tint 1 1/2 cups red/orange (small amount) combination
Tint 1/2 cup black (thinned with 1 1/2 teaspoons corn syrup)
Tint 1/4 cup orange/red (small amount) combination
Reserve 3/4 cup white
Decorate in Numerical Order 1. Use tip 3. Fill in mouth on the Elmo Cake with black icing (smooth with finger dipped in cornstarch).Outline smile using tip 3 with black icing
2. Use tip 3. Fill in nose with orange/red icing combination (smooth with finger dipped in cornstarch)
3. Use tip 3. Fill in eyes on the Elmo cake with white icing (smooth with finger dipped in cornstarch). Fill in pupils with tip 3 in black icing (smooth with finger dipped in cornstarch)
4. Use tip 16. Cover face with stars with red/orange icing combination
Baking Instructions Preheat oven to 350°F or temperature per recipe directions. Your cake will unmold easily, without sticking, when you prepare the pan properly. Grease the inside of pan using a pastry brush and solid vegetable shortening (do not use butter, margarine or liquid vegetable oil). Spread the shortening so that all indentations are covered. Sprinkle about 2 Tablespoons flour inside pan and shake so that flour covers all greased surfaces.
Turn pan upside down and tap lightly to remove excess flour. If any shiny spots remain, touch up with more shortening and flour to prevent cake from sticking. (You can use vegetable oil pan spray or vegetable oil pan spray with flour, in place of solid shortening and flour or use Wilton Cake Release, for perfect, crumb-free cakes!).
Make one 2-layer cake mix according to package or recipe directions. Pour the cake batter into pan, and if necessary, spread the batter around with a spatula to fill all areas of the pan evenly. Be careful not to touch sides or bottom of pan.
Bake the Elmo cake on middle rack of 350°F oven for 30-40 minutes or until cake tests done according to recipe directions.
Cool the Elmo cake at least one hour. Brush loose crumbs off cake.
Remove the Elmo cake from oven and cool on cake rack for 10 minutes. While the cake is still in the pan, carefully slice off the raised center portion of the cake. This allows the cake to sit more level and helps prevent cracking. To remove the Elmo cake from the pan, place cooling rack against cake and turn both cake rack and pan over. Lift pan off carefully.
To transfer cake to serving board, hold a cake board against cake and turn both cake and rack over. Lift off rack. Hold another board against bottom of cake and turn cake over. Be sure to hold cake, rack and board close together while turning to prevent the Elmo cake from cracking.
This perky pachyderm cake brings a ton of birthday greetings to the party (he?s made from our Stand-Up Cuddly Bear Pan). Treat the guest-of-honor to a special Jumbo Muffin of his own or add more muffins for larger parties.
PLEASE NOTE: If you had an account on the previous version of Wilton.com you will need to reset your password. We apologize for the inconvenience but it necessary to maintain security of the information you have entrusted us with. Our goal is make it easy so you can make it amazing!
Get inspiration and great deals
Yes, I want to receive new decorating ideas and exclusive offers from Wilton. You can withdraw your consent at any time.